Book Reviews

So we’re halfway through May and I’ve been reading voraciously. While I will be adding these reviews to my Book List, I thought I’d devote a specific post to reviewing the books I chose for Green Bean’s Bookworm Challenge.

The first was Slow Food Nation by Carlo Petrini. I was looking forward to reading the story about how this movement started, a movement that many credit as the first big stand against modern industrial food production. Alas, I confess that I found it mostly to be a dry read. I’m not sure if this is because I’ve already run ahead of the topic with Michael Pollan and Barbara Kingsolver, both great storytellers. Or because the book just focussed a bit too much on the definition of “gastronome” for my liking. I enjoyed the little “diary stories” scattered throughout – the rest seemed like an exercise in semantics (though I do get that, back then, alot of what he was proposing was newer than it seems now).

The second book I’ve read is Stuffed and Starved: markets, power, and the hidden battle for the world’s food system by Raj Patel. This is a heavy read, but fascinating. Patel seems to pick up where Pollan left off in The Omnivore’s Dilemma, taking the issue of modern industrial food production to its historical (and largely political) roots. I was stunned, for example, to realize that Food Aid – which on the surface seems like the ultimate altruistic endeavour – is actually as politically motivated as campaigns like “free” infant formula for mothers in the third world, or disposable pads for school girls in Africa. Turns out that dumping vast amounts of wheat, corn, and soy (a product of government subsidies and policies that encourage overproduction) into countries that had not historically relied on them for staples creates an almost instant consumer base. Local staples cannot compete with the influx of ultra-cheap goods in the form of “aid”, but when the aid is gone the locals are now dependent on the “Global North” (aka: the developed nations) for food. World hunger and the current food crisis, as it turns out, have little to do with scarcity of food, but with the politics of its distribution and trade. This book is an important read for anybody wishing to truly Know Their Food, a meaty read full of facts that will make you shake your head in despair at times (but it does end on a positive note).

Finally, I whizzed through Michael Pollan’s latest offer, In Defense of Food. This is for folks who read books like The Omnivore’s Dilemma or Stuffed and Starved and are left wondering “what the heck can I do about this?”. But it’s not just full of advice like “eat local” or “shop at farmer’s markets”. Pollan also uses the opportunity to expose the pseudoscience that is nutritionism. Not that nutritionism is necessarly faulty science, but its application to the question of “what should we eat” is just totally inappropriate. And it has provided fuel for the processed food industry, not to mention clouded our collective common sense with a bunch of techno-speak that really doesn’t make any sense when you stop and think about it. Pollan’s writing style kept me turning pages and enjoying the experience. A great, simple, but important read.

Categories: know your food | 3 Comments

Post navigation

3 thoughts on “Book Reviews

  1. I’ve recently seen Stuffed and Starved noted in a number of places and Raj Patel’s name seems to be everywhere I read about food so I was excited to read your review of his book. I’m reading Uncertain Peril – Genetic Engineering and the Future of Food that also addresses food aid and the dumping of genetically engineered commodities on hungry countries that have little choice. I always thought food aid was such a pristine act of kindness it’s shocking to discover otherwise. I’m glad the book ended on a postive note. Thank you for the review. I’m going to look at reading it.

  2. Thank you for such thoughtful book reviews. I have to say you certainly are voracious. Half of the book reviews from “bookworms” are from you! šŸ˜‰ Way to go, girl!

    I’ve read IDF and totally agree with your summary. Quick and important read.

    Slow Food, umm, I think I’ll skip that one. I too have read OD and AVM – beautiful books that cannot be surpassed.

    Stuffed and Starved, wow, that one sounds like a definite keeper. I’m going to order it from my library right now. Thanks for the write up!

  3. ruralaspirations

    Green Bean, the challenge wasn’t much of a challenge for me – I stay up way too late reading in bed and this was just the excuse I needed, lol.

    Katrina, thanks for visiting! I heard about this book when CBC radio interviewed the author. I hadn’t heard about it on any of the blogs I frequent so thought it would be a good book to bring to the bookworm challenge.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: